Anal Creampies: Sexy Bake Sale!

Only special bake sales sell fresh anal creampies.

Me and my girlfriends were in charge of our catholic school fundraiser. We didn’t have too many skills at the time to make money. It was too cold that time of year to do a car wash, and we weren’t qualified to do any tutoring. We came up with a bake sale, we’d bake pies! However, on the day of the sale, the pies weren’t selling. We thought we were out of luck, then Chastity had an idea. “Oh my god, we should sell creampies!” We all thought she was crazy, there was no way we could bake new pies now. Chastity rolled her eyes, “No you idiots, not those kinds of creampies, anal creampies!”  She said she knew many of us catholic schoolgirls were virgins, so regular creampies likely wouldn’t happen. Plus selling anal creampies was going to be much hotter for the wealthy schoolboys.

We had to be discreet about selling our anal creampies.

Chastity, contrary to her name, was a bit of a slut. She had straight A’s but also made some D’s straight too. She was the smartest slut in school, makes sense that she could be business savvy. Chastity had a plan for us to sell our own anal creampies without getting caught. She would let her many lovers and potential new prospects over to our table. They would pay a ticket for whichever girl they wanted, and there was an option to “make anal creampies” with one of the girls, but there was also an option to “eat freshly made anal creampies.” By offering those options, we were able to make double the value of our anal creampie sales.

Through word of mouth, we had many schoolboys coming (or should I say about to cum) to buy our anal creampies. Chastity fashioned the janitor’s closet into our ‘baking room’ as we called it. We didn’t ask how she got the keys to it, but the school janitor looked extra happy that day. I was the first to go to the baking room. Chastity walked Blake, over to me. She whispered, “So, Blake has a ‘thing’ for you and I told him how it was your first time doing anal, so he paid extra!” I couldn’t believe someone wanted to make anal creampies with me, but then I found another surprise. Turns out Blake had a girlfriend named Janice, but she knew he was going to make some anal creampies with me. Blake’s girlfriend wanted to eat the freshly made anal creampie that Blake and I would make!

Janice and Blake took me into the baking room. I was nervous but then Janice started to kiss me as she flipped up my skirt and began to remove my panties. “Hey sexy,” said Janice “I’ve been watching you in that tight skirt…” Janice started to reach down between my ass cheeks and started fingering my asshole. Then she said ” And my pussy got so wet when my man said he thought you were hot too!” When she fingered my asshole, she started to make me bend over. I heard Blake say he thought it was so hot seeing me and his girl making out. Then he tapped his cock on my asshole as Janice kept kissing my neck. Janice’s other hand went to my pussy and she whispered “cum for us pretty girl.” Then Blake started kissing my neck and then kissing Janice and then me.

“I’ve always wanted to make some anal creampies with you,” said Blake.

Blake slid his cock into my asshole, then Janice’s hands were touching my pussy. I felt stuffed and soaked. Janice opened her shirt, made me suck her tits, and encouraged me to take Blake’s cock. I was moaning as his cock was pumping so hard and deep inside me. Janice even spanked me as Blake kept pounding my asshole, “You like that you dirty schoolgirl?” I couldn’t answer. Janice grabbed my neck and said “Come on, take my boyfriend’s cock, make some anal creampies for us!”

I felt Blake’s cock twitch inside me as he yelled “Oh god, I’m about to cum!” Janice took her free hand and started rubbing my clit, her other hand still on my neck. I felt my pussy lips clench as she played with me, but my asshole got tighter too! Blake pulled in my hips and pumped faster. “Come on little schoolgirl, fuck my boyfriend, make him cum!”  Finally, Blake busted into my asshole, and Janice immediately got to her knees and began to lick out all of his cum. But Janice took her time devouring my freshly made anal creampie. She even stole a little sample of my pussy too, but I didn’t mind.

Blake and Janice gave me their numbers in case I wanted to ‘bake’ with them again. And after we sold our anal creampies we had enough to raise money for several of the catholic school charities and extracurricular activities! We even had a huge profit for all the girls involved in the bake sale. The school priest and the nuns were so amazed at how well our pies sold, we just never told them what kind of cream was in our pies.

Hungry for some anal creampies? Kiera can feed you today if you call her now!!!
Or you can catch some more anal fun with her blogs every Tuesday!

Call Kiera 1-888-664-0295